Why "Bad Mom vs. Good Mom" Shouldn’t Define Us?

In a world where judgment comes fast and harsh, moms often find themselves under a microscope. Whenever someone makes a questionable choice or stumbles off society’s well-worn path, one question lingers like an accusation: How were you raised? And so, without knowing a mother’s story, society casts blame in her direction, using her as the measure for her child’s every action—good or bad.

As mothers, we carry an invisible weight, an unspoken rule that we must mold our children into the world’s idea of “good” to avoid the sting of judgment. We live in a world obsessed with labels, constantly comparing “good moms” to “bad moms,” as though motherhood could be distilled into a checklist. And this pressure isn’t just about others’ opinions; it’s also about belonging. We all crave acceptance, a deep-rooted need to feel like we fit in, like we belong, especially in a society that places mothers under constant scrutiny. But here’s the truth: the happiest people, and often the happiest mothers, are those who break free from others’ expectations. They focus on what feels right for them, not what they think they should do to avoid judgment.

But let’s face it—it’s nearly impossible to tune out the world all the time. When our children face hardships, mess up, or simply don’t live up to society’s standards, guilt rushes in, like an unwelcome visitor. We think, What did I do wrong? Could I have prevented this? Am I a bad mom? Even though life has taught us that we can’t control every twist and turn, we shoulder the burden anyway, believing that every mistake our children make somehow reflects our own failings.

Recently, I saw two heart-wrenching stories unfold that showed just how deep this blame goes. In one, a young woman on a reality show was criticized for not fitting the mold of a “proper Filipina”—she was bold, outspoken, and unapologetically herself. Yet, the world didn’t just judge her; they judged her mother, questioning her upbringing, blaming her for her daughter’s personality, as if a mother could singlehandedly control every aspect of her child’s choices.

In another case, a mother discovered her 13-year-old daughter had been manipulated by someone online, a predator disguised as a friend, who took advantage of her innocence and trust. This mother had done everything she could to protect her child, yet she couldn’t shield her from every hidden threat. Still, she blamed herself, questioning every decision, replaying moments in her mind, thinking she should have somehow known.

In situations like these, it’s always the mother who faces judgment first. Society’s knee-jerk reaction is to look at her, as though mothers alone bear the weight of their children’s choices. Fathers don’t face this same scrutiny. The role of mothers in our culture often reduces us to caretakers and emotional anchors, seldom seen for the strength and resilience it takes to raise a child, let alone to navigate a world that constantly questions our every move.

But here’s a thought: What would our world look like without mothers? If we didn’t have the nurturers, the caregivers, the fierce protectors who pour themselves into raising the next generation, how would society hold up? Yet, despite all we give, mothers are often the least appreciated, the most easily criticized. So maybe it’s time to stop comparing ourselves to impossible standards of “good” or “bad.” Instead, let’s remember our worth, the love we give, and the strength it takes to keep going in the face of judgment and hardship.

As mothers, we deserve kindness—especially from ourselves. We’re allowed to make mistakes, to learn, to grow, and to forgive ourselves. We need to be compassionate with ourselves because being a mom isn’t easy. It’s messy, exhausting, and at times heartbreaking. But in all the hard moments, there’s beauty too. Let’s reward ourselves not with labels of “good” or “bad” but with love and understanding. We’re doing the best we can, and that is enough.

------

Want to hear the latest studies on today’s generation from the country’s top experts and advocates? Join us in-person or virtually for the first-ever mother convention addressing the latest issues and concerns in parenthood. Reserve your spot via MOMCON2024 link, and use the discount code MOTHERBOSSFORMOMCON to get a special rate. Let’s connect, learn, and grow together as a community of strong, compassionate mothers.